Where to Find the Best Hidden Gem Cheesecake Around Fayetteville
Whether you just have a craving or you are hosting a Golden Girls themed get together, cheesecake is always a popular menu addition around Fayetteville. Believe it or not, this…

The Fayetteville area has several hidden gem cheesecake bakers. You have to try all of these out.
Ryzhkov Photography / ShutterstockWhether you just have a craving or you are hosting a Golden Girls themed get together, cheesecake is always a popular menu addition around Fayetteville.
Believe it or not, this popular dessert was invented by the Greeks in early Fifth Century B.C!
With lots of refinements and recipes swapped around the world, we now have the crowning jewel of comfort food and decadence. According to cheesecake.com (of course there's a cheesecake.com!), the cheesecake we know and love today didn't come around until the late 1800s, after cream cheese was accidentally invited in 1872.
"Of course, no story of cheesecake is complete without delving into the origins of the New York style cheesecake. The Classic New York style cheesecake is served with just the cake – no fruit, chocolate or caramel is served on the top or on the side. This famously smooth-tasting cake gets its signature flavor from extra egg yolks in the cream cheese cake mix.
By the 1900s, New Yorkers were in love with this dessert. Virtually every restaurant had its own version of cheesecake on their menu. New Yorkers have vied for bragging rights for having the original recipe ever since. Even though he is best known for his signature sandwiches, Arnold Reuben (1883-1970) is generally credited for creating the New York Style cheesecake. Reuben was born in Germany and he came to America when he was young. The story goes that Reuben was invited to a dinner party where the hostess served a cheese pie. Allegedly, he was so intrigued by this dish that he experimented with the recipe until he came up with the beloved NY Style cheesecake."
To satisfy your hankering for this delectable dessert, I've gathered some of the best local places to enjoy some cheesecake around Fayetteville! Enjoy!
Betties
Located in Hope Mills and serving the local area, Betties not only brings a fun style and retro vibe with their logo, they offer a wide variety of cheesecake flavors! From Snickerdoodle, churros and cookies and cream, they all look delightful. The standout out with Betties are the keto cheesecakes they offer, making a diabetic and sugar conscious option available to those who would usually have to forgo dessert! Hit them up for full size flavors and prices, or grab a slice in downtown Fayetteville at the Rude Awaking Coffeehouse.
No physical location.
Chocy Balls & Moore
Located in Raeford, Chocy Balls and Moore is home to a New York Style Cheesecake that will knock your socks off! The also have various other treats such as the chocolate dipped potato chips and candy kabobs, providing something for everyone's palette.
No physical location.
Website: https://www.chocyballs.com/shop
Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Torta dolce al formaggio! Italian for sweet cheesecake and you can't go wrong Gusto Napoletano's cheesecake of the day or their fried cheesecake.
2711 Raeford Rd Suite 112, Fayetteville, NC
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/gustonapoletano/
The Cheesecake Guy
Christopher Hossley, aka The Cheesecake Guy is making waves in our local scene with his sweet creations. Veteran owned and operated, The Cheesecake Guy has so many flavors to choose from! The stunningly classic cherry cheesecake to my favorite the Key Lime French Meringue, there is something for every occasion!
No physical location.
Check out his Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/BossHossVeteran